Last year Apple went where I
never thought it would, with the iPad mini bringing the Apple tablet
experience to a brave new budget world.
Now usurped by the new iPad Mini 2,
the older tablet is still on sale at a wallet-friendly £249 for the
basic version, with 16GB of storage on offer for the Wi-Fi version on
Apple's site (although it can be had slightly cheaper if you shop
around).
You
can also add 4G cellular, which brings the price up to £349. This
entry-level model comes in a single 16GB capacity, while the iPad mini
with Retina display goes up to 128GB, costing a whopping £659 for the
top model which also includes 4G.
Then
again, the first generation iPad mini isn't about top-end specs with a
whopping price tag – it's about beating the likes of the Google Nexus 7 and Amazon Kindle Fire HD in the budget stakes.
The
two competitors have been getting plenty of column inches thanks to
their super-cheap prices and the impressive specs on board. But with
both offering only a 7-inch screen compared to Apple's 7.9-inch display,
the Cupertino company is confident its device will win over
budget-conscious consumers.
However,
more frugal shoppers may not agree with this idea, as the Nexus 7 and
Kindle Fire HD cost quite a bit less. When faced with a choice between
the three, they might opt for the familiar Amazon brand or the sheer
power of the Nexus 7, with its impressive spec list and legions of
Google apps.
That said, Apple fans need not worry too much when it comes to whether the iPad mini
is a worthy addition to the iBrand. It comes with enough power and is
Ive-inspired enough to make it a worthwhile addition to the range. This
isn't a shrunken-down iPad, it's a whole new product all over again.
Be
it the larger screen size, impressively low weight or alternative
design compared to the competition, there's a lot to chew over when it
comes to the iPad mini. But is it worth spending your hard-earned cash
when a handful more will get you larger version of Apple's tablet? And
how does it stack up next to the second-generation mini with its higher
resolution display and faster hardware?
Features and design
The
iPad mini exists because the market started to dictate its presence…but
that doesn't mean Apple doesn't want to put its own spin on things.
To
that end, the border has been reduced and the screen is larger at 7.9
inches relative to the dimensions of the original iPad. Additionally,
the design is completely different to the likes of the Google Nexus 7.
In fact the whole ethos has been created from the ground up, partly
under the stewardship of Sir Jony Ive, according to Apple.
None
of that really matters though. What is important is the fact that it's a
superbly designed device that gives a measure of why it costs so much
more than the likes of the Kindle Fire HD.
The aluminium chassis shares the same colouring as the iPhone 5S, with the darker black slate and white silver options both bringing a touch of class to proceedings.
At
308g it's twice the weight and then some of the iPhone 5S, but compared
to other tablets on the market (and combined with the aluminium
chassis) it feels lightweight in the hand.
The
screen is something of a worry though – with the 1024x768 resolution in
the expansive display, you only get a sharpness akin to the iPhone 3GS.
While the display quality is better than that thanks to improved IPS
LCD technology, it's still light years behind the Retina display on the
bigger iPad Air and the second-generation mini.
If
you own a modern iPad, you'll notice the difference straight away. But
then if you have one of these, then you won't want an iPad mini.
The tablet will struggle to impress iPhone users, as it doesn't have the wow factor of Apple's smaller devices.
In a side-by-side test of the same movie running on the iPad mini, the Nexus 7
and the Kindle Fire HD, the iPad looked the least impressive (although
the contrast ratio was certainly more than decent in my eyes).
Then
there's the issue of holding the actual tablet. As Apple says, it's as
light as a pad of legal paper, and there's definitely no risk of it
causing wrist strain. However, the iPad mini doesn't really lend itself
that well to any manner of grip.
The
most comfortable and secure way to hold a tablet is to grip right
around the back – something Apple thinks you can do easily according to
its promotional materials.
Well,
you're wrong there, Cupertino-gadget-people. It's just too far to
stretch around with average-sized hands. Instead you're forced to hold
it in the corner, covering part of the screen. It's good that Apple has
chucked some technology in there to distinguish an intentional touch
from an accidental one, but it's not the most comfortable way to use the
device.
In landscape
orientation using two hands, the iPad mini is a much nicer device to
hold, with the aluminium covering giving it a nicely textured back.
However, the aluminium covering similar to the iPhone 5 has led to
another design problem: scratching.
The
handsets have been getting criticism for exposing the silver metal
below with minimal scratching. This started to happen within a day on
the iPad mini – which is all the more confusing seeing as it doesn't
live in the pocket with keys and coins.
It's
something we hoped Apple would have changed in the manufacturing
process, and means you'll need to keep an eye on how you look after the
tablet or invest in a protective case immediately.
The
top and bottom of the bezel are wide enough to comfortably rest your
hands on, while web browsing and accelerometer-based gaming in landscape
orientation is excellent.
The
rest of the design is predictably ergonomic. The volume rocker keys are
close but not too near to the mute switch on the top right-hand side.
This
is near the power button, which is intuitively placed to be easy to hit
when you want to reactivate the iPad mini… although many will just hit
the home button to achieve the same thing.
The
traditional Apple home key remains, although it's shrunken somewhat to
fit into the smaller chassis. However, during testing I found it just as
easy to hit, despite the dinkier dimensions.
It's
interesting that Apple has popped the headphone jack at the top of the
iPad mini, given it's put so much effort into repositioning it at the
bottom of the iPhone 5S and 5C... but I do prefer it staying above the screen.
The
speakers sit at the bottom of the iPad mini, flanking the Lightning
connector, which offers faster speeds of data transfer and can be
connected either way round. This is handy when you're charging before
bed and can't be bothered to put the light on.
The
speakers provide decent enough sound, but in landscape mode they create
a distorted sense of audio because of their mono-directional firing.
The
processor inside is Apple's last-generation A5 effort, which may worry
some, but it's likely to be enough for most actions, coupled as it is
with 512MB of RAM. It's still miles away from the raw grunt of the new
Google Nexus 7 or the iPad Air with its A7 processor, but Apple reckons
it helps it hit a sweet spot in terms of price.
Apple
also has expertise in optimising iOS to run as well as possible on
older hardware, and iOS 7.1 certainly restored a lot of the snappiness
that had been lost with the move from iOS 6 to 7.
You probably won't think that, though, because the iPad Mini won't easily fit in your pocket, or even your jacket pocket. It's more of a purse, small bag, or large-coat-pocket device. It'll fit wherever you'd fit a softcover book.
The construction feels solid, stellar, fun to hold. The home button clicks crisply. It doesn't feel like a lower-priced product in your hands. It might be, in terms of form, the most addictive iOS product in existence. And it's perfectly sized for kid hands. It's far more suited for use in cars and traveling.
But the Mini shouldn't be a surprising product. A device smaller than the iPad that can run apps? That's always existed. That's called the iPhone. The really impressive feat of the iPad Mini, the surprise, is that it seems to handle all the iPad's normal duties while being shrunken down. All except effortless onscreen typing, although it comes close.
Interface and Performance
Onto the iPad mini interface. iOS
7 was a complete redesign that ditched the gradient-heavy look that had
been around since the introduction of the first iPhone.
While
it was a bit of a shock at first, the general consensus is that it was a
much-needed shake-up by Jony Ive who replaced the ousted Scot Forstall
as interface designer.
Gone
are most of the shadows in favour of a much flatter design. Since iOS 7
runs on all recent iPads, iPhones and iPod touches (I'm currently
testing version 7.1 here), it should be a familiar experience to anyone
with an existing Apple device.
Holding
the iPad mini in portrait mode is easy enough thanks to the weight.
Prodding the icons on screen isn't too difficult, nor does it feel like
you're going to push the tablet out of your hands and onto the floor.
The
iOS interface is simplicity itself. Any users not familiar with Apple's
mobile operating system will pick it up in no time. The icons are
presented in a 4 by 5 layout, and unlike on the iPhone they rotate when
you move the tablet into landscape format.
The
ability to place icons in the bottom dock means you can have the apps
you want on the home screen. Dragging and dropping said apps on top of
one another allows you to create folders with ease, which you can rename
to anything you want.
With
iOS 7, Apple has greatly improved the number of controls you can access
directly from the Home screen, and indeed from any screen.
To
enter the app switcher, simply double-click on the Home button to see a
Cover Flow-style view of all your app windows. Swiping left and right
lets you see all the apps that are open but in a 'suspended' state,
while tapping on one launches it.
Swiping
on the screens themselves scrolls them normally, but swiping on the app
icons moves them more quickly, which is great if you have lots of apps
open that aren't currently in use. Force quitting apps is done in this
view by swiping upwards on an app window, and you can use two fingers to
quit two apps at once.
As
iOS matured, there were increasingly loud grumblings about the fact that
many commonly used controls were buried in subsections of the Settings
app, with only volume, brightness and AirPlay available via quick
controls. Thankfully Apple has addressed this with a new control overlay
that you call up by swiping upwards from the bottom of the screen.
There
are buttons here for volume and brightness, AirDrop and AirPlay, music
or video playback, as well as shortcuts to the clock, timer and camera
functions. Perhaps best of all, a row of five buttons in the centre
provides quick on/off switches for Airplane mode, Wi-Fi and Bluetooth,
Do Not Disturb mode and rotation lock.
These
were almost all available in iOS 6 but much more fiddly to get to,
requiring drilling down into various different Settings menus. Do Not
Disturb is a new, handy mode that stops all notifications except for any
you choose specifically to allow.
The
Lock screen will show the cover art of any music track that's playing
and also gives you playback and volume controls as well as a shortcut to
Camera mode. Handily, the Control Centre overlay can also be swiped in
from the Lock screen.
Searching
your iPad is done using Spotlight and this is revealed from any Home
screen by swiping downwards form the centre of the screen with one
finger.
It searches pretty
much all the content on the device, though you can exclude certain
things like Notes or Messages from searches in the Settings. If you
search for something that isn't on the device you get an option to run
the search on the web or Wikipedia.
However,
Apple is still catering for the iPad owners with some handy gestures to
make things easier to move around. Instead of double tapping the home
button to switch apps, touching the screen with four fingers and swiping
left and right will move you through the most recently-used apps, and
pinching all digits together will return you to the home screen.
This
is really helpful when using the tablet on the move, as it means you
don't need to shuffle the palm around to hit the home button - and it's
really cool too. It's an even more intuitive system on the iPad mini
than the iPad 'proper', as it somehow fits the screen size better.
By
default, iOS 7 does quite a lot of animation when you open and close
apps, and has a slightly space-age "parallax" effect that uses the
built-in gyroscope to move the wallpaper slightly to the left or right
depending on how you tilt the device.
This
isn't to everyone's taste: indeed some users reported it gave them
motion sickness. Luckily it can be disabled by going into Settings >
Accessibility and choosing Reduce Motion, where you will also find
options to increase contrast and reduce transparency effects.
Disabling
these settings lightens the processing load, so they are worth looking
at if you're not particularly partial to zooming.
The
Notification Centre, revealed by swiping down from the top of any Home
screen, can show notifications from any supported apps and you can
enable or disable these using the Settings app.
By
default you'll see a Calendar view with a weather summary, but you can
also see messages, emails, eBay notifications and much more here if you
choose to switch them on.
Apple
might be criticised for bringing older technology to the iPad mini, as
the A5 chip with 512MB of RAM doesn't sound like a lot when you can buy
the quad core Google Nexus 4 smartphone with 2GB of RAM for the same price as the mini, and with the same amount of storage too.
However,
in practice it's really rather hard to fault Apple's interface
performance when using the device in day to day use. It's definitely not
got the grunt of the larger new iPad Air or even the iPad mini 2, but the performance of iOS 7.1 even on this older hardware is still perfectly acceptable.
The
only real gripe, and it's one you'll hear time and again from me
throughout this iPad mini review, is the fact that the screen is too
low-res.
It simply saddens me
to see menus we're used to on both iPads and iPhones not having the
same sharpness as before... and we're certainly not used to seeing Apple
take a step back in quality.
If
you've never used a top end smartphone or tablet, this won't be an
issue as the display is fine, and technically still HD in terms of pixel
count. But the Retina display on the mini 2 is unquestionably superior
and once you're used to Retina quality the lower resolution of the older
screens is very noticeable.
Gripping, swiping, and typing: Thumbs and fingers
So, what about that smaller bezel? Holding it suddenly becomes a delicate-seeming proposition. I worried I'd accidentally start an app with my big palms, or turn a page by accident. That didn't happen to me. Apple has worked finger-rejection technology into the hardware and software of the iPad Mini that's context-dependent. All I know is that when reading books on the Kindle app or iBooks, I found holding on the side wasn't a problem. When I typed, the entire edge-to-edge surface became sensitive to my entire hand.
In landscape mode, the longer and thicker top and bottom bezel come in handy: it offers more of a grip when viewing videos, and I found that it also helped make the iPad Mni comfier when playing games.
The tweener size of the Mini means you can hold it in portrait mode and thumb-type like on an iPhone or iPod. It works pretty well, for the most part. I was even able to thumb-type in landscape mode, with a little stretching. Typing more traditionally works better than I expected, although I became more of a finger hunt-and-pecker than a spread-finger typist. The 7.9-inch display certainly isn't as wide as the average laptop keyboard, and the virtual keys, while well-sized, require a bit of adjustment to use.
You can also hold the iPad Mini in one hand and thumb-swipe, but I wouldn't recommend it. It's not as intuitive as on an iPhone, although it could be fine for simple page-turning taps.
The screen: Retina-free
Your feelings about the iPad Mini's screen will all depend on how much time you've spent with Retina Displays or high-pixel-count devices. If you own a recent iPhone or the last iPad, you'll feel that this screen is blurry. Text isn't as sharp. The pixels per inch don't even match what's available on a Kindle Fire HD or Nook HD. The iPad Mini has a 1,024x768-pixel display, just like the iPad 2's, but writ smaller with a denser pixel count per inch. However, the smaller-screened Kindle Fire HD has a 1,280x800-pixel display. So does the Google Nexus 7. The Nook HD has an even higher-res display at 1,440x900 pixels.
All three cost considerably less than the iPad Mini, and all three have much higher, denser pixel counts. The iPad Mini's 7.9-inch screen has more physical real estate in terms of square inches (let's just call it an 8-inch screen, because it very nearly is), but fewer pixels per inch. You're trading size for high-res crispness.
So, the iPad Mini not only has a lower-resolution screen than much of the competition, but it's probably the least impressive screen of Apple's 2012 stable of iOS devices. The iPod Touch, iPhone 5, and fourth-gen iPad all seem brighter, more vibrant, and far higher-definition.
However, if you've used an iPad 2, the text is crisper. It's readable, even with smaller fonts such as those used in e-mail. With games and videos, you won't notice quite as much because graphics and videos are often in constant motion. Even there, though, I could see a clear difference playing HD videos and a variety of games. The IPS display has excellent wide-angle viewing, and it's very bright. It may not be as good as a Retina Display, but it's every bit as good as the iPad 2's screen. I held both up side by side and found the colors and vibrancy to be similar, although the iPad Mini is less bright at its highest setting. In deeper, in-depth tests using CNET's TV-testing equipment, the iPad Mini's display was revealed to indeed be less bright at its highest setting, but also less color-accurate than the nearly-perfect Retina Displays on the iPhone 5 and third and fourth-gen iPads. When looking at photos or movies, you can definitely tell the difference side-by-side.
Even if, for all the incredible design that the iPad Mini has going for it otherwise, that screen feels like a comparative letdown, there's big ace in the iPad Mini's hole. A huge one, actually. It has to do with aspect ratio.
This 7.9-inch display isn't 16:9 like the iPhone 5 or most Android tablets. That means the screen width is wider, more like a page of a book. It's the same as on the iPad, but on this smaller screen, with the iPad Mini's shrunken-down side bezels like an iPod Touch, it feels extra-wide. Web pages fit more across the screen, allowing the text to be bigger. More importantly, digital magazines and illustrated books can be rendered without squishing down too much.
Apple's made a big deal of this, but let me tell you the real killer apps here: the future of digital publications. Textbooks. Basically, any layout-sensitive graphically intensive e-books. The iPad Mini doesn't squish that content down like what often happens to it on 16:10 7-inch screens. An iBooks version of DK Publishing's "Dinosaurs" looked wonderful and engaging. So did the kids' book/app "Bobo Explores Light."
Maybe most impressively, nearly every larger iPad app I've thrown at it feels usable and comfortable at this smaller screen size. Board games with tiny buttons, media-editing apps, games with virtual control pads, and even using the onscreen virtual keyboard. It's book-size, but the apps feel largely the same.
You could be of two minds about this. Yes, the non-Retina Display means text that's less sharp. It feels like a miscalculation on a device so clearly targeted at reading. Yet, hold the iPad Mini back a foot and increase the font size, and you probably won't notice.
The more booklike 4:3 aspect ratio and its more natural compatibility with PDF files, comics, magazines, and layout-sensitive graphic novels give the iPad Mini an edge over other 7-inch tablets. For pure text, the Mini may not be the best. For other media, it has its advantages, even without a Retina Display. I never found myself unable to enjoy a magazine or book, although I did find myself wishing the resolution were sharper (reading the "Dark Knight Returns" comic, in particular).
iPad Mini as video player
That 4:3 aspect ratio has a drawback, of course, and that's video playing. Movies and HD TV shows will inevitably be more letterboxed than on a 16:9 tablet like the Nexus 7 and Kindle Fire HD. On a Retina Display iPad, you at least have enough pixels to make for sharp video viewing in the space provided. On a 1,024x768-pixel display, it means the letterboxed video has an even lower resolution.
Most shows still look very watchable, no worse than on the iPad 2 (and a little better since the pixels are smaller), and there are plenty of apps and services that the iPad Mini is compatible with, from subscription-based streaming to cable accessory TV apps to video stores like iTunes and Amazon Video on Demand. The iPad Mini has the greatest flexibility for apps and services among competing tablets, which is its huge edge.
Two speakers tucked on either side of the Lightning connector on the bottom edge pump out decent volume for such a small device. They're good enough to listen to music and videos with. Two aluminum volume buttons on the right edge are flat like on the iPhone 5, but longer, and not tapered like the plastic iPad's volume button. They're easy to feel for and press.
iOS 6
For more on all the various features of iOS 6, read CNET editor Jason Parker's full review. Most the iOS 6 features you'd expect are here, including Siri, which is curiously absent from the equally well-equipped iPad 2. Apple's Passbook app, oddly, didn't make the cut, even though it's included on the iPod Touch.
Of course, Apple's controversial Maps app is also present, with 3D Flyover and direction capabilities. I haven't been able to test whether turn-by-turn works on the LTE version.
Siri
Oh, hello Siri – what are you doing here? Given the iPad 2's processor is the same as in the iPad mini, surely it can't handle Siri? So however did it find its way onto this device? (Yes, I'm looking at you, Apple.)But, there it is, and nicely incorporated too. The little pop-up window that gives access to the voice recognition is nicely unobtrusive. The accuracy is much improved over the first iteration of the software, and the range of functionality also enhanced.
With its ability to tell you how your football team is doing, what the weather's like in Paris and to open an app on command, the iPad mini has the same implementation as the iPhone when it comes to Siri…and therefore as much use.
There's no way you'll ask it to book an appointment for you, because a) it doesn't always work, and you'll wish you had just typed it in, and b) you're likely to be with someone, and the risk of failure and looking stupid in front of them is too high to try it.
The Google Now cards on Android are much better when it comes to information, as being told what's going on with your team is easier than having to ask for it. Both are different systems, but Siri is never going to gain mass appeal until it finally becomes almost unerringly accurate at recognising what you're saying.
I still like the little pop-up window, though, and you can now hold down the home button for as long as you need to speak to Siri which makes the process a little easier.
iPad Mini as camera
One improvement in the iPad Mini compared with the iPad 2 is its cameras. It has a 5-megapixel iSight rear-facing camera and a FaceTime HD front-facing camera, the same cameras that are on the third-gen iPad and later. The fifth-gen iPod Touch has a better camera, with more features and an LED flash. The Mini lacks app features such as HDR and Panorama, although other apps from the App Store have those functions.
The point is, the Mini's cameras are more than good enough for snapshots, 1080p video recording, and high-quality FaceTime calls. They're above average for budget-tablet cameras. Holding the iPad Mini is an easier affair, so it's also feasible to use this device to take photos and video, something I've yet to see a normal friend of mine do with a larger iPad. It's not your next point-and-shoot, but it could do in a pinch. Photos taken with the Mini turned around are about as good as any iPad photo I've ever seen.
The iPad Mini even has its own little Smart Cover ($39) available in six colors, although the design is different from the larger version available for the 9.7-inch iPad. The all-polyurethane design doesn't have an aluminum latch, so it grips more softly to the Mini's side. The cover also has one fewer segment in its folding design.
The Smart Cover still folds up to be a stand or a keyboard riser, but it joins into a similar triangle with no fold-over. It's just strong enough to support the iPad Mini, working equally well for typing and for picture-stand use. And it feels a bit more fun on a smaller device.
Unfortunately, just like with the larger iPad, the Smart Cover doesn't protect the iPad Mini's back. People will be tempted to buy a full-body case or a back cover as well.
In the box: Lightning and charger, no headphones
The included gear is -- as always -- limited when it comes to the iPad. The iPad Mini includes a Lightning cable and an AC adapter, which is actually the smaller version that comes with the iPhone 5. The two are cross-compatible. No larger AC brick is needed.
EarPods, Apple's newly designed headphones, are not included. Earbuds never came with any other iPad, either.
The new Lightning connector, introduced with the iPhone 5, is easier to plug in and takes up less space, but most other gadgets use Micro-USB. Extra Lightning cables can add HDMI-out and camera/SD card slot input capabilities. If you have older 30-pin connectors you can use a separate adapter, although it's not guaranteed that it'll mean a fit with older accessories and devices.
Battery life
Apple claims 10 hours of battery life for the iPad Mini, 9 hours using LTE. That's equivalent to the claims for the larger fourth-gen iPad, and iPads in general going back to 2010.
Our battery test told an even better story: the iPad Mini held up through 12.1 hours of video playback, which is remarkable for such a small tablet. The Nexus 7, comparatively, only lasted 8.4 hours on the same test. Over a week of use the Mini seemed to last well more than a full day of use, and then some. After playing games, streaming videos, downloading large files, and using the tablet for everything I could think of, I had a hard time fully depleting its battery over the course of a single day. The new fourth-gen iPad lasted an hour longer at 13.1 hours, but you'd expect it to.
Source
Engadget Apple iPad Mini Reviews (Critic Reviews 8.6/10, User Reviews 8.8/10)
CNET Apple iPad Mini Reviews (CNET Editor's Rating 4/5, Average User Rating 3.5/5)
The Good The iPad Mini's
ultrathin and light design is far more intimate and booklike than the
larger iPad, and its cameras, storage capacities, optional LTE antenna,
and general functionality offer a full iPad experience. The screen's
dimensions elegantly display larger-format magazines and apps.
The Bad The
iPad Mini costs too much, especially considering the lower resolution of
its 7.9-inch non-Retina Display. The A5 processor isn't as robust as
the one in the fourth-gen iPad and iPhone 5. Typing on the smaller
screen is not quite as comfy.
The Bottom Line If
you want the full, polished Apple tablet experience in a smaller
package, the iPad Mini is worth the premium price. Otherwise, good
alternatives are available for less money.
Where to Buy
$299.99 New Egg Apple iPad mini 16GB 7.9" Wi-Fi - White/Silver (MD531LL/A)*$1.99 Shipping
$299.00 Walmart Apple iPad mini 16GB Wi-Fi (Space Gray or White)*free shipping availabe
$263.89 Ebay Apple iPad mini 16GB, Wi-Fi, 7.9in - Space Gray*APPLE WARRANTY FREE PRIORITY SHIPPING
$299.99 Best Buy Apple® - iPad® mini Wi-Fi - 16GB - Space Gray*free shipping
$279.45 Amazon Apple iPad Mini MF432LL/A (16GB, Wi-Fi, black)*free shipping