Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon Touch: The Thinkpad ultrabook gets a high-end Windows 8 touch

The Thinkpad Ultrabook Gets a High-End Windows 8 Touch

High performance laptops are nothing new, but until recently they were hulking beasts that could break one's back if carried out of the house. Things have changed - it's now possible to have top performance in ultra-portable packages, as demonstrated by the Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon Touch Ultrabook.

It's hard to classify the Lenovo's direct competitors due to the huge variety of Windows 8 hybrids and laptops on the market. The rulebook has been ripped up and with a traditional laptop design with an added touchscreen, the Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon Touch is one of the more conservative offerings. High performance laptop hybrids such as the Sony Vaio Duo 13 spring to mind, as do traditional Ultrabooks such as the Dell XPS 13 and MacBook Pro with Retina display.

The original 2012 Lenovo X1 Carbon was the best ThinkPad money could buy, but now Lenovo has added a touchscreen panel and changed Windows 7 Professional for Windows 8, bringing last year's model right up to date.

The result is a formidable machine that not only offers the best usability and performance, but also a fantastic Windows 8 experience. However, the eye-watering price tag of £1,779 / US$2,139 / AU$2,538 means this experience doesn't come cheap.

Pick the Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon Touch up and it's immediately apparent that you're holding a different class of laptop. ThinkPad has always been a predominately business brand and you'll have seen the familiar black matt chassis punctuated by that red mouse pointer in Starbucks and train stations all over the place.

Being a ThinkPad, the X1 Carbon Touch retains the looks synonymous with this illustrious range, but the similarities with bog-standard corporate machines end there. Yes there's the red mouse nipple, which is bemusing when a touchscreen and full-sized trackpad are on offer, but it's an example of how important the look of the X1 Carbon Touch is to Lenovo.

However, when you pick up the Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon Touch for the first time, the solid, flexless build, smooth rubberised finish and lightweight chassis can't fail to impress. The fact that this machine weighs just 1.5kg (3.3lbs) yet counts as one of the most powerful Ultrabooks on the market speaks volumes about what Lenovo has achieved.

Other Ultrabooks that have tried to achieve this balance of weight and power have ended up scrimping on build quality - such as the HP Envy 15 with its awful trackpad or the Acer Aspire S7 and its keyboard, but the Carbon oozes quality from every port.

From the beautifully spaced and comfortable keyboard that enables immediate, accurate speed typing to the smooth and responsive trackpad to the luxurious panel that manages to marry vibrancy and clarity with a non-reflective finish.

Windows 8 review

It's not just the weight - or lack of - that makes the Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon Touch such a engineering triumph, it's also the thickness. Despite measuring 22mm (0.87 inches) at its thickest point - a not exactly size-zero waistline - the Carbon's wedge shape gives it the impression of blade-like thinness. It's alluring to look at and commands attention, attracting admiring comments from those around you.

However, to ace a TechRadar review, you need more than alluring looks. So let's get under the hood and see how good the Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon Touch really is.

The expected ThinkPad amenities are standard, including vPro management, TPM, a fingerprint reader, and even an optional integrated WWAN (3G) radio. The carbon fiber cover and cage are, in Lenovo’s parlance, “satellite quality,” and the chassis certainly feels more durable than Sputnik.

Lenovo also hasn’t forgotten about the things that users actually care about. Audio is impressive and Dolby-certified. The keyboard is backlit and fully usable, and the glass touchpad was rock solid on this go-round with the Carbon. (The 2012 unit I tested had a disturbingly loose one.)

Only two complaints marred my experience with the X1 Touch. Foremost is battery life. While I managed to score an extra half hour of video playback versus the old X1, at 3.5 hours of running time, it is still at the bottom of the heap of Windows 8 laptops when it comes to longevity. The screen is also relatively dim, and colors look a bit washed out in comparison to other recent-model laptops.

Of course, there’s also the not-insubstantial price to consider, too. The X1 Touch starts at $1,350 and, as configured, runs a hefty $1,729. That’s cheaper than the non-touch Carbon I reviewed in the fall, but still a huge investment in a laptop, and hundreds of dollars more expensive than the competition in this space. (Acer’s 14-inch Aspire M may be heavier, but it’s less than half the price.)

If you’re trying to convince your boss to buy one for you, my recommendation is lean heavily on the bit about the satellite.

WIRED Excellent combination of performance, portability, and durability. Still the best keyboard going. Trackpad issues resolved. You want bells and whistles?

TIRED Probably the most expensive computer in its class. Screen not as impressive as the previous generation. Battery life upgraded, but still not enough.

Specifications

Under the hood is an Intel Core i7 processor 3667U, the U in that pithy moniker indicating that it's one of the ultra low-power chips designed for Ultrabooks. It packs considerably more power than the likes of the Asus Zenbook or Samsung Series 9, since it's clocked at an impressive 2GHz.

The benchmark scores from our lab tests back this up too, with a top-end performance resulting in roughly 10 per cent more power than rival Ultrabooks such as the Asus Zenbook.

The Core i7 chip is also left to handle the graphics tasks in the absence of a dedicated graphics card. It has become the norm for manufacturers to leave 3D graphics to the onboard processor now, but it means that despite the sky-high price tag, the Lenovo ThinkPad Carbon X1 isn't the best choice for heavy video editors or gamers.

Elsewhere there's a whopping 8GB of RAM, an amount normally reserved for gaming machines or high-end powerhouses such as the Samsung Series 7 Chronos. This helps keep the Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon Touch noticeably quick, helping a slick, breathless performance.

There are several models of the Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon Touch at a range of price points, and our model packed a 256GB SSD drive, the highest you can get. The only criticism here is the lack of usable space, and of the 256GB on offer, only 190GB was usable.

Of course, the 14-inch, 1600 x 900 resolution panel is a key part of this updated Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon Touch, and while we'd like to have seen 1080p included given the price, it's still a good performance.

The colours look great, it's pin sharp despite not being Full HD and it's as great for watching a movie as it is for working on a presentation. What's more, the touch sensitivity is as good as we've seen on a Windows 8 device, and it's miraculously free from smearing.

For a laptop that measures 22mm at its thickest point, connectivity is underwhelming, with two USB 3.0 ports, one of which can charge devices when the laptop is sleeping.

There's also DisplayPort for connecting to external monitors and an SD card, but no Ethernet, HDMI or VGA, which will mean carrying extra dongles to your meetings. However, business users will love the fingerprint reader and hard drive protection.

Performance

Benchmarks
Cinebench 10: 11,498
3D Mark: Ice: 32,650 Wind: 3787 Fire: 512
Battery: 192 mins

With a score of 11,498 in our processor tests, it's clear that the Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon Touch is a formidable machine. This kind of score ranks among some of the best performing Ultrabooks on the market, and even manages to give the next generation of Intel processors a run for their money.

Other than top multitasking and app switching speeds, the i7 processor speeds up boot times, enabling it to go from cold to a usable Windows 8 home screen in roughly 15 seconds. Even better is the resume from sleep, which averaged around four seconds, partly due to Windows 8's improvements and of course that wickedly fast chip.

However, there's a downside. The high performance third generation Intel Core i7 chip colludes to suck power from the Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon Touch, especially under heavy strain. The result is an uninspiring three hours of battery life in our test, which involves looping a high definition clip with full screen brightness until the laptop dies.

Three hours is one of the lowest Ultrabook battery scores we've seen, and should ring alarm bells for anyone who intends to use the Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon Touch at high load while away from mains electricity.

Turning the screen brightness down and sticking to moderate web tasks increases lifespan to around four hours, which is still underwhelming when you consider the Samsung Vaio Duo 13 running Intel's latest Haswell fourth generation processor managed six hours in the same test.

If you spend long periods on the road, you could be frustrated by the disappointing longevity, especially given the Ultrabook's sky-high price tag. Intel's new chips, announced in May and being released in earnest later this year, will offer better longevity and battery performance, which makes the £1,779 / US$2,139 / AU$2,538 price seem even less appealing.

As with most Ultrabooks there's no dedicated graphics, and while games might be playable on lower settings, it's in no way suited to overly creative tasks or heavy video editing. We wouldn't normally pull up an Ultrabook for this failing, but then most Ultrabooks don't cost this extraordinary sum.

Connections, and battery
Like many business systems, the X1 Carbon skips the SD card slot (a security concern for some), but you do get two video outputs, both HDMI and Mini DisplayPort. Ethernet requires a dongle, but Lenovo would no doubt like you to use one of its OneLink docks to add additional connectivity, including DVI, full Ethernet, and four USB 3.0 ports. That standalone dock costs $179, a hefty additional investment, but I use an older USB-powered version, and have found it to be excellent.

In our benchmark tests, the Core i5-powered X1 Carbon performed as expected when compared with other recent ultrabooks with higher-than-1080p displays. Nearly all these systems have fourth-gen Core i5 CPUs, from Intel's ultra-low-power line (except the Toshiba Kirabook , which has a previous-generation Core i7), and you'll find any of these more than powerful enough for everyday personal and business tasks, from putting together PowerPoint presentations to social media and Web surfing to streaming HD video.

Given all that, what we're really looking for from the X1 Carbon is amazing battery life. A slim, on-the-go laptop needs to last all day, and while the X1 does well, it's not a long-lived as some. The system ran for 5 hours, 41 minutes, in our video playback battery drain test, which is merely OK, and not in the same ballpark as the 13-inch MacBook Pro, nor even the Samsung Ativ Book 9 Plus or Lenovo Yoga 2 Pro. Keep in mind that all of the systems mentioned here have better-than-HD displays.

Conclusion
The third version of the ThinkPad X1 is the best to date, and it remains one of the only choices for a slim, high-design business laptop with premium features. The addition of both a 2,560x1,440-pixel-resolution display and the adaptive function key row is welcome, but these upgrades also drive the price up high enough that you're likely to have to twist some arms to get your IT department to get this as your next work laptop.

Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon (2014)
Windows 8.1 (64-bit); 1.6GHz Intel Core i5-4200U; 8GB DDR3 SDRAM 1,600MHz; 1,792MB (shared) Intel HD Graphics 4400; 128GB Samsung SSD.

Pages

Prof. Price

Friday, April 18, 2014